Group information: 201732120110	Zheng Xiaoyu

Date: 2019-04-13

[0.5/2] Requirements must be testable.

      No explicit test cases.  


[1/2] Specified acceptable responses to undesired events.

      "The file contains an optional head line": how to handle the case of no head line?
      "AT1G01046 	0 	0 	0": how to handle the case of 0/0?

      
[1.8/2] Readable and understandable by customers, users, and designers.

       "logogram": this is a rarely seen word.
       "Valid submitted gene expression file has the following format" -> "A valid gene expression file has the following format"
       " has a upload file button " -> "  has an upload file button "
       " When the biologists upload a plain text file which has two samples of different levels of expressed genes and each sample represents a experimental condition.": this is Not a complete sentence.
       " If the biologists upload an invalid gene expression " -> "If the biologists upload an invalid gene expression file"
       " Before analyse:" -> " Before analysis:"
       " After analyse:" -> " After analysis:"
       " (you can image an ordinary login interface)": delete this sentence.
       "restrict the accessing time within 5 seconds.": ???
       "Since the application is designed for a wildly used application, it should have a cross platform compatibility to satisfy various users. Thus": delete.
       "The maintenance of the database. ": Are you sure OMG needs a database?
       "basically functions": basic functions
       "some constrains about the application": some constraints about the application


[0/1] Specifies changes anticipated in the future (for both environment and software)
      
      No change cases.


[1/1] Structured to be easy to change.

        "Web maintenance & Security": you can entirely omit this section or make it shorter.

	
[0.7/1] Consistent, complete, unambiguous, and realistic.

        "aimed at idengtifying a gene expression file"  -> identifying differentially expressed genes
	"make the software more completely." -> make the software better.
	"while C is the gene expression level from a control sample": add a period.  How to handle the case where C=0?
	"user characteristics - constraint - specific requirement": I could not see these chapters "user characteristics" and "specific requirement"
	"The scatter plot displays differentially expressed genes.": the plot has many points closely along the diagonal line.
	"the app requires only 500GB of RAM to support the use of visitors": Are you sure 500GB is realistic? Did you mean disk space?

	
[0/1] Specifies what should not do as well as what should do.

---------------------------------------------------------------

[5.0/10] Total


Other comments:

Please see the comments after each check item.